Dizi Planet
The Return of Martin Guerre (Le Retour de Martin Guerre)

The Return of Martin Guerre (Le Retour de Martin Guerre)

Movie · 1982 · 15 people

Daniel Vigne directed The Return of Martin Guerre (Le Retour de Martin Guerre), a French period drama in which Gérard Depardieu and Nathalie Baye play the main parts. Its story comes from a genuine 16th-century French case of a man taking another's identity, and the film lasts about 122 minutes. It opened in France on 14 May 1982 and won Césars for best music, original screenplay and production design.

The story follows a peasant and former soldier who returns to his native village after about ten years without news. Martin Guerre is taken back by his wife Bertrande and his family. Some villagers, however, suspect that he is not the real Martin but a man who has taken over his identity, and the accusation ends up in court. Besides Depardieu and Baye, the cast includes Bernard-Pierre Donnadieu, Roger Planchon, Dominique Pinon, Isabelle Sadoyan and Tchéky Karyo.

Jean-Claude Carrière, Vigne and the historian Natalie Zemon Davis wrote the screenplay. The film is a fictionalised version of the account that Jean de Coras, the judge who heard the case, published in 1561. Alexandre Dumas also told the story in Les Deux Diane. It was later remade in America as Sommersby (1993), with Jodie Foster in the part Baye played.

DirectorDaniel Vigne
Production companySociété Française de Production, France 3

Reactions

You can pick up to 3 reactions.

Cast

Names without a link have no profile here yet.

Nathalie Baye Nathalie Baye Actor · died at 77 Bertrande de Rols Tchéky Karyo Tchéky Karyo Actor · died at 72 Augustin Gérard Depardieu Bernard-Pierre Donnadieu Roger Planchon Dominique Pinon André Chaumeau Chantal Deruaz Isabelle Sadoyan Jean-Claude Perrin Maurice Barrier Maurice Jacquemont Neige Dolsky René Bouloc Daniel Giraud

Titles sharing this cast

Through different eyes

History & Society Lens Asks about the period, the social background and what the work reflects.

Based on a real case of identity fraud in sixteenth-century France, the film shows a village world where who you are rests largely on the testimony of neighbours, relatives and your spouse. The return of a man unheard of for about ten years reveals how decisive communal memory and suspicion could be. Having the historian Natalie Zemon Davis among the writers, and drawing on the account published in 1561 by Jean de Coras, the judge who saw the case, gives the film a serious historical footing. Watching the trial unfold, you can grasp the logic of an age in which the community largely decided who a person was.

Cinephile Looks at script, editing and directing choices; keeps a distance from formula films.

Daniel Vigne's film builds a sober courtroom suspense without getting lost in costume-drama ornament. The script, co-written by Jean-Claude Carrière, keeps the audience in the same uncertainty as the villagers and turns doubt into the dramatic engine. The tension between Gérard Depardieu's physical, earthy performance and Nathalie Baye's quiet but layered Bertrande is the film's heart. Its César wins for music, original screenplay and production design confirm its level of craft. My reservation is about pace: it takes its time establishing village life and may test impatient viewers. Set beside the later American remake Sommersby, this version arguably feels plainer and more convincing.

These are not reader reviews: they are short editorial takes written from different viewer perspectives with AI assistance. Reader reviews are below.

Reviews (0)

Log in Log in to write a review.

Comments